The key points of the procedure for shareholders to convene the shareholders' meeting on their own After the meeting, the transfer of responsibilities: take the third interim shareholders' meeting held by New Wave Energy in 2025 as an example.
Abstract: When the board of directors and the board of supervisors fail to perform their duties of convening shareholders' meetings, qualified shareholders may convene and preside over shareholders' meetings on their own in accordance with the law. Taking the third interim shareholders' meeting of New Wave Energy in 2025 as an example, this paper analyzes the legal points in the order of the shareholders' meeting, the conditions of shareholding, the procedure of the meeting, the effectiveness of the resolution and the transfer of responsibilities after the meeting, and distinguishes the procedural differences between listed companies and limited liability companies for the reference of enterprises with shareholder disputes.
1. public events
according to the announcement of trendy energy and media reports, the company received the request of shareholders to hold an interim shareholders' meeting on June 19, 2025, and the board of directors made a veto resolution on June 28. Shareholders submitted a request to the Supervisory Board on June 30, which rejected it on July 4 and did not give notice of the meeting within five days of receiving the request.
On July 8, six shareholders holding a total of 14.99 of the shares notified the company to convene its third interim shareholders' meeting in 2025.
However, the company announced on July 9 that the convening letter did not specify the matters to be considered and specific proposals, and the self-convening procedure did not conform to the regulations. On July 24, the meeting was held in Yantai as scheduled, taking a combination of on-site and online voting, with 1,195 shareholders and proxies present.
Beijing Global Law Firm issued a legal opinion that the convening, convening procedures, qualifications of attendees, qualifications of conveners and voting procedures of the meeting were in compliance with the law and the company's articles of association, and the voting results were legal and valid. On July 30, the company announced that it had obtained a business license and official seal, and Chairman Zhang Junyu was registered as the legal representative.
2. control structure
according to media reports, Itai B shares acquired about 50.10 percent of New Wave Energy through a tender offer at the end of May 2025, with the original board of directors and management still in office. In his book, Chen Hui argues that corporate control includes at least the shareholders' meeting level, the board level and the management level. The change of shareholding ratio needs to be transmitted to the board of directors through the shareholders' meeting procedure, and the right to convene the shareholders' meeting has become the focus of this dispute.
Analysis of 3. Rules for Convening Shareholders' Meeting
in terms of the order of convening the shareholders' meeting, Article 114 of the Company Law stipulates that if the board of directors of a joint stock limited company is unable or fails to perform its convening duties, the board of supervisors shall convene and preside over the meeting in a timely manner; if the board of supervisors does not convene and preside over the meeting, shareholders who hold more than 10% of the company's shares individually or collectively for more than 90 consecutive days may convene and preside over the meeting on their own.
If a shareholder holding more than 10% of the shares requests the convening of an interim shareholders' meeting, the board of directors and the board of supervisors shall make a decision within 10 days from the date of receipt of the request and reply in writing to the shareholders.
Article 63 of the Company Law applies to a limited liability company, and shareholders representing more than one-tenth of the voting rights may convene and preside at their own discretion, without the requirement of a continuous shareholding period. If the company has an audit committee to exercise the functions and powers of the board of supervisors, the audit committee shall assume the corresponding responsibilities. A listed company shall also comply with the Rules of the Shareholders' Meeting of Listed Companies, the Rules of the Stock Exchange and the Articles of Association of the Company.
In terms of the effectiveness of resolutions, Article 26 of the Company Law stipulates that if the meeting convening procedures and voting methods violate laws, administrative regulations or the company's articles of association, shareholders may request the people's court to revoke the resolution within 60 days from the date of the resolution, but there are only minor defects, Except those that have no substantial impact on the resolution.
In terms of change registration, Article 35 of the Company Law stipulates that if a company changes its legal representative, the application for change registration shall be signed by the legal representative after the change.
4. applicable conditions
the procedure described in this paper takes a limited liability company and a listed company as an example, and the convening subject, shareholding conditions and notice period of a limited liability company shall be determined in accordance with the limited liability company section of the company law and the articles of association of the company. During the handover after the meeting, according to media reports, the former directors, supervisors and senior managers of trendy energy did not arrive to cooperate with the handover. the transfer of seals, account books, bank authority and overseas subsidiaries needed to be handled separately through reminders, lawsuits, property preservation and notification to the bank that opened the account.
5. recommended companies
first, before issuing a request to convene a meeting of shareholders, shareholders should confirm the proportion of shareholding, the period of shareholding and the special provisions of the articles of association.
Second, the request letter states the topic and specific resolutions, retains the service certificate, and records the reply or overdue situation of the board of directors and the board of supervisors.
Third, the notice of the meeting shall be issued and announced within the statutory time limit, and the check-in form, power of attorney, voting and counting records shall be kept completely, and lawyers shall be invited to witness.
Fourth, after the resolution is made, the new legal representative shall sign the application for change of registration, urge the original management in writing to hand over the seal, license, account book and bank authority, and file a return lawsuit in the name of the company if necessary.
Author profile: Chen Hui lawyer, lawyer of Guangdong
, Executive Dean of Zhiheng College, senior corporate equity lawyer. Lawyer Chen Hui has long focused on legal services for corporate equity and corporate governance. His business direction covers equity structure design, corporate control arrangement, equity incentive, partnership mechanism, articles of association design, investment and financing structure design, equity dispute resolution and corporate governance mechanism construction. He is the author of "Outstanding Partner-Equity Design and Incentive" and "Understanding Partner Mechanism in a Book".